Building a Passive Portfolio: Do Smart Beta Indices Add Something Different? 19Nov2026
This is my 548th blog since 2010. Over the years, I have covered global financial markets, with a focus on India, and continue to share insights to help readers understand complex topics in simple language.
The views expressed here are for information purposes only and should not be construed as a recommendation or investment advice. While the author is a CFA Charterholder with nearly 25 years of experience in financial markets, this content is intended to share general insights and does not constitute financial guidance.
Dhirendra Kumar of Value Research Online is a doyen of Indian mutual fund industry. He advocates simplicity over complication. His general recommendation: three or four funds are sufficient to achieve one's long-term investment goals.
For many investors, passive equity funds are good enough for wealth creation over time. They can build their passive portfolio with a combination of broader indices and smart beta indices.
While selecting mutual funds, it's better to consider funds with different risk exposures. If two funds offer the same underlying risk exposures, it does not help in diversification.
This article examines three Nifty broad market indices and eight selected Nifty "smart beta" indices from a different perspective.
Rather than comparing returns or identifying the best-performing strategy, we look at stock and sector concentration, constituent overlap and the differences in underlying exposures.
The objective is straightforward: to help individual investors understand whether combining one or two broad market passive funds with a couple of smart beta funds can provide meaningful diversification, without making a passive portfolio unnecessarily complicated.
After all, the idea is not to own more passive funds, but to understand what each fund actually adds to the portfolio. As you know, passive funds consist of exchange traded funds or ETFs and index funds.
All the data are as of 31Oct2026, unless otherwise stated.
(article continues below)
---------------
Related blogs:
Top 10 Equity Indices Powering Passive Investing in India: October 2026 Review 17Nov2026
Nifty Smart Beta Indices Review – September 2026 10Oct2026
Nifty Indices Broad Market and Sector Review – September 2026 08Oct2026
Nifty Indices Broad Market and Sector Review - August 2026 06Sep2026
Nifty Smart Beta Indices Review - August 2026 06Sep2026
Nifty Indices Broad Market and Sector Review – July 2026 02Aug2026
Factor Investing in India: Do "Smart Beta" Indices Outsmart Nifty 50 and Midcap 150? 24Nov2025
Nifty Midcap 150 Quality 50 Index: Has Quality Lost Its Edge? 10Aug2025
Decoding the Nifty Midcap 150 Quality 50: A Midcap Strategy Built on Fundamentals 07Aug2025
Passive Titans of India: The Top 10 Equity Indices by Fund Size 17Jul2025
Analysis of Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 Index 12Sep2023
---------------
2. Features of Nifty indices:
As can be seen in the chart 1 below, we are examining:
A. three Nifty broad indices, and
B. eight Nifty "smart beta" indices, consisting of:
> three momentum indices
> two volatility indices
> two quality indices
> one equal weight index
Six of the eight smart beta indices have assets under management or AUM of Rs 2,000 crore or more (as of 31Oct2026) and two quality indices are added for their quality factor (for more on this, check Chart 6 below).
Chart 1 delineates the features of the 11 Nifty indices the article is examining:
3. Stock level concentration: Top 1 to 10 stock weights:
Chart 2 showing Stock level concentration of Nifty indices: Top 1 to 10 stocks weights:
Key observations from Chart 2 above:
> Nifty 50 is the most concentrated among the broad market indices -- its top 10 stocks account for 53 per cent of the index, compared with 33.9 per cent for Nifty Next 50 and just 16.8 per cent for Nifty Midcap 150.
> Momentum indices show relatively high stock concentration and so is Nifty 200 Quality 30 index
> Low Volatility indices generally show lower concentration versus other smart beta indices
> Nifty 50 Equal Weight (top 10 stocks' weight 23%, lowest among selected smart beta indices) stands out as equal weighting clearly reduces dependence on the largest stocks
> Midcap smart beta exposure does not automatically mean lower concentration -- both Nifty Midcap 150 Momentum 50 and Nifty Midcap 150 Quality 50 have higher top-10 concentration than the broad Nifty Midcap 150
Overall takeaway: Smart Beta indices are not necessarily more diversified than conventional broad-market indices.
The number of stocks in an index does not necessarily determine how diversified it is. What matters is how much weight is assigned to its largest constituents.
4. Stock overlap analysis:
Chart 3 below shows the extent of stock-level overlap between selected Nifty broad market and smart beta indices, both in terms of common stocks and their combined weights in each index.
Using the chart, investors can discern potential duplication in stock exposure when investors combine multiple passive funds, helping assess whether a new fund brings meaningful diversification to the overall portfolio.
Chart 3 showing portfolio overlap analysis of selected Nifty broad and smart beta indices (31Oct2026):
What exhibit 3 above reveals:
1) You can try a variety of combinations with these indices. The author tried only 16 interesting combinations.
2) Nifty 50 has no common stocks with Nifty Next 50 or Nifty Midcap 150, while Nifty Next 50 and Nifty Midcap 150 also have no common constituents.
Similarly, Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 has no common stocks with Nifty Midcap 150. The reason for this is the fact that they have different underlying stock-selection universes.
3) Nifty 50 Equal Weight has complete stock overlap with Nifty 50. All 50 stocks are common. However, their weights differ substantially because of the equal-weight methodology.
For example:
As on 31Oct2026, HDFC Bank's weight in Nifty 50 is 9.95 per cent, but its weight Nifty 50 Equal Weight is just 1.91 per cent due to equal weighting criteria.
Likewise,
ICICI Bank: 9.39% vs 2.14%
Infosys 3.92% vs 2.40%
Tech Mahindra 1.07% vs 2.35%
4) Pairs with substantial stock overlap are:
> Nifty 50 and Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30, with 25 common stocks (83.3 per cent overlap) and common stock weights of 65.6 and 83.8 per cent respectively
> So, combining Nifty 50 with Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 may offer limited additional stock diversification, given that 25 of the 30 stocks overlap and account for 83.8 per cent of the Low Volatility index.
> Nifty 200 Momentum 30 and Nifty 500 Momentum 50, with 23 common stocks (76.7 per cent overlap) and common stock weights of 77.5 per cent and 73.9 per cent respectively
> Combining both these two momentum smart beta indices may not result in any diversification benefits
> Nifty 50 and Nifty Alpha Low Volatility 30 indices have 20 common stocks, offering limited diversification
> Nifty Alpha Low Volatility 30 and Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 have 17 common stocks -- this combination too fails the test of diversification
> Momentum indices show significant overlap with one another
As shown above, combining Nifty broad index with smart beta index or a combination of two smart beta indices, with substantial overlap with each other, may provide limited additional stock diversification.
Investors are better off avoiding such pairs.
5) Pairs with lesser stock overlap are:
> Momentum and Quality appear to have relatively little stock overlap. Nifty 200 Momentum 30 and Nifty 200 Quality 30 share just three stocks (10 per cent), with common stock weights of 9.1 per cent and 8.5 per cent respectively
> Likewise, Nifty 200 Momentum 30 and Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 have little stock overlap
> Nifty 50 with Nifty 200 Momentum 30 offers an interesting combination too
> Such pairs with little stock overlap are most likely to offer well diversified portfolios to investors
Overall:
Pair of indices Assessment
Nifty 50 and Low Volatility 30 Very high overlap
Nifty 200 Mom 30 & Nifty 500 Mom 50 Very high overlap
Nifty 50 and Alpha Low Vol 30 Very high overlap
Two Low Volatility indices Significant overlap
Momentum 30 and Midcap Momentum 50 Meaningful overlap
Momentum 50 and Midcap Momentum 50 Meaningful overlap
Nifty 50 and Equal Weight Same stocks, different weights
- Different Smart Beta strategies can have substantial overlap with conventional broad-market indices.
- Indices following the same factor strategy, particularly Momentum, can have considerable stock duplication.
- Different factor strategies, such as Momentum and Quality, may offer greater differentiation in stock selection.
- Investors should look beyond the index name and examine which stocks they are actually buying.
- Sector concentration and the overall portfolio allocation also matter (see Charts 4 and 5 below).
5. Sector concentration matrix
In section 3 and 4, we examined stock level concentration and stock overlap of Nifty indices. Now, let us assess sector level exposures too.
Charts 4 and 5 below examine sector concentration across the selected Nifty broad market and smart beta indices, identifying their dominant sector exposures and the weight of their leading sectors.
They show how much each index depends on its top 1, 3, 5 and 7 sectors.
The objective is to help investors understand sector-level concentration and assess whether combining different passive funds introduces genuinely different sector exposures.
Chart 4 showing Sector concentration matrix of 11 Nifty indices: individual sectors dominating the index (data as of 31Oct2026):
(click on the chart to view better)
Chart 5 showing Top sector weights of Nifty indices (data as on 31Oct2026):
What charts 4 and 5 reveal:
a) The three momentum indices show particularly high sector concentration. The top three sectors account for 62.6 per cent in Nifty 200 Momentum 30, 71 per cent in Nifty Midcap 150 Momentum 50 and 69 per cent in Nifty 500 Momentum 50.
Their top seven sectors account for 92–98.1 per cent of the respective indices.
b) Quality indices also show considerable concentration. Nifty 200 Quality 30 has 66.6 per cent in its top three sectors, led by IT (27.8 per cent) and FMCG (23.9 per cent). Nifty Midcap 150 Quality 50 is relatively more diversified across its top sectors.
c) Low Volatility indices show significant concentration. Their top three sector weights are 55 per cent and 48 per cent, respectively. However, financial services, healthcare and FMCG feature prominently in both.
d) Nifty 50 Equal Weight has a relatively balanced sector distribution, due to its equal weighting strategy.
e) Among broad-market indices, Nifty Next 50 has the lowest top-three sector concentration (47.7 per cent). However, its top seven sectors account for 79.9 per cent, higher than Nifty 50 and Nifty Midcap 150.
Section summary:
- Momentum indices exhibit particularly high sector concentration, especially in capital goods and financial services.
- Quality indices have distinct sector preferences, particularly IT and FMCG.
- Equal Weight offers a more balanced sector distribution than conventional Nifty 50.
- Low Volatility does not necessarily mean low sector concentration.
- In six of the 11 indices assessed, financial services and capital goods are among the top 3 sectors by weight.
6. Investability of Nifty indices
Chart 6 provides an interesting perspective on the availability and popularity of passive investment products tracking the selected Nifty indices.
For a comprehensive analysis of India's top passive equity funds, check here.
Chart 6 showing investability metrics, like, number of passive funds and the asset size (data as of 31Oct2026):
Key observations from Chart 6:
1. Nifty 50 dominates the passive fund landscape. So is Sensex index (not shown here).
2. The remaining two broad indices too have considerable investor interest as reflected in number of passive funds and their asset size.
3. Among smart beta indices, Nifty 200 Momentum 30 leads in AUM, at Rs 11,118 crore, followed by Nifty 50 Equal Weight at Rs 7,983 crore and Nifty 100 Low Volatility 30 at Rs 6,323 crore.
4. Momentum strategies have attracted a relatively wider product offering.
5. Quality indices have a relatively small product presence.
Overall:
The passive investment product landscape remains heavily dominated by Nifty 50 and Sensex.
Among smart beta strategies, Momentum and Equal Weight have gained relatively greater product traction.
It may be noted that the number of funds and their aggregate AUM indicate product availability and market adoption, not necessarily investment quality or future performance.
7. Action button: Building a passive portfolio
For individual investors considering passive equity funds (ETFs and index funds), a simple core-satellite approach may be worth considering.
> Build the core with one or two broad-market indices, depending on your preferred large-cap, next-tier or midcap exposure
> Add one or two smart beta strategies that offer complementary stock and sector exposures
> Examine stock overlap, stock concentration and sector concentration before combining funds -- different index names do not necessarily mean better diversification
> Check fund size (AUM), expense ratios and tracking difference; for ETFs, also examine trading volumes, liquidity and bid-ask spreads
> Avoid accumulating multiple passive funds with substantially similar underlying exposures
The author's personal preferences (not recommendations) are the following, considering the broad market exposure as well as smart beta strategies:
> Nifty 50 + Nifty Midcap 150 + Nifty 200 Momentum 30
> Nifty 50 + Nifty Midcap 150 + Nifty 200 Quality 30
> Nifty Midcap 150 + Nifty Low Volatility 30 + Nifty 200 Momentum 30
There is no need to own all available indices or smart beta strategies. Around three or four carefully selected passive funds may be sufficient for many individual investors, depending on their financial goals and risk appetite.
The key is not how many passive funds you own, but whether each fund brings something useful and different to your portfolio.
This isn’t investment advice. Even though the author is a CFA Charterholder with nearly 25 years of experience in the financial markets, this is just general insight—not a recommendation. Safe to assume the author holds a few of the investment ideas discussed above.
- - -











