The
Indian Hotels Company Limited has been consistently making losses ever since
the 2008 global financial crisis hit the company very badly. The company is
commonly known as Taj Group of Hotels, owned by Tata Sons.
As
shown in the above table, the company made very big losses in 2009-10, 2010-11
and 2012-13. Even in 2008-09 and 2011-12, the company’s profits were very
meager. The total losses between 2008-09 (after the global financial crisis)
and 2012-13, on a consolidated basis, amounted to Rs 639 crore.
But
these massive losses did not deter the company from paying hefty dividends to
shareholders. Around 38 percent of the total stake in the company is owned by
the promoters, the Tatas. While the consolidated losses were Rs 639 crore in
the last five years, the total dividends paid were Rs 380 crore during the same
period.
While
there is nothing unlawful about this, valid questions can be raised against the
prudence of the company’s management in doling out liberal dividends.
Is
this how the Tatas milk their companies, even though loss-making, for their own
benefit—in the form of dividends? It is a known fact in the corporate world
that when business conditions are horrible, companies skip dividends altogether
or cut them drastically to weather the difficult conditions.
Why
can’t the company use the precious cash to retire its massive debt and bring
down the large interest cost, instead of doling out dividends?
The
company made huge acquisitions in the US ,
Australia
and others. It tried to take over the US-based Orient Express Hotels when it
bought 6.9 percent stake in the company in 2007. But Orient Express rejected
Tatas’ overtures.
Now
these investments and acquisitions turned out to be lemons (with the benefit of
hindsight). And the shareholders of Indian Hotels have suffered in the last
five to six years, as the company is saddled with massive debt.
Indian
Hotels has disappointed the equity investors and is not making any amends to
its profligate ways. Can the company do some soul searching now that its
adventures have become very costly?
If
the Tatas admit their costly mistakes humbly, it would do a lot of good for
their corporate governance practices.
Is
anyone at Securities and Exchange Board of India (the capital market regulator)
or the company’s board of directors listening?
Corporate
governance is dead! And long live corporate governance!
- - -
Disclaimer: The author is an investment analyst, equity
investor and freelance writer. The author has a vested interest in the Indian
stock markets. This write-up is for information purposes only and should not be
taken as investment advice. Investors are advised to consult their financial
advisor before taking any investment decisions. The author owns equity shares
in the above mentioned company. He blogs at:
For FY 2013-14, Indian Hotels posed a loss of Rs 554 crore on a consolidated basis. For the first time since 1974-75, the company skipped dividends in FY 2013-14. The company has been making losses since 2009-10 (consolidated basis). At long last, it dawned on the company not to pay dividends.
ReplyDelete